A group of New York City exotic dancing clubs sued New York state Thursday, saying it’s not fair that they’re being kept closed when everything from axe-throwing venues to bars with live music and casinos can open up.
The lawsuit filed in Manhattan federal court claimed that thousands of employees are forced out of work by the state’s ban due to the coronavirus. Defendants included governor Andrew Cuomo and the state’s liquor licensing authority.
Exotic dancing clubs including Starlet’s, Sugar Daddy’s and Gallagher’s 2000 in the borough of Queens asked the court to declare it a violation of the first and 14th amendments to the US constitution to keep their clubs closed while letting other enclosed establishments open up.
The lawsuit comes as the state’s widening of rules for bars and restaurants have led many to open this week.
It also was filed after similar clashes between establishments that allow nudity or dancing in other states.
In December, a judge in California let two San Diego strip clubs make their own determinations about providing a safe environment for dancers and patrons during the pandemic.
A spokesperson for the governor’s office said the lawsuit attempts to undermine “science-based public health measures”.
“While we are working to reopen as many facets of the economy as quickly and safely as possible, science, data and common sense dictate that exotic dancing is not allowable at this time,” spokesperson Jack Sterne said in a statement.
The lawsuit, which seeks unspecified damages, maintains that four strip clubs in Queens have been ready to open with Covid-19 safety protocols since the early days of the pandemic.
They pledged to require masks and temperature checks for guests and employees, to keep everyone safely apart and to engage in frequent cleanings of all surfaces with ample supplies of disinfectant throughout the clubs.
Yet, the lawsuit said, Cuomo and the state have ordered restaurants and bars “with exotic dancing to remain closed while permitting night clubs, lounges, jazz dinner theaters, churches, axe throwing venues, billiards halls, event venues for weddings, casinos, restaurants and bars with live music and bowling alleys that pose similar or greater risks of Covid-19 transmission to reopen.”
According to the lawsuit, at least 41 other states allow similar businesses to remain open.
New York state formally outlawed the operation of strip clubs during the pandemic in early July despite allowing live music indoors, the lawsuit said.
It noted that other indoor establishments were also allowed to open at various times, including Saturday Night Live in October.
In recent weeks, Cuomo has announced that large establishments like Madison Square Garden can open and movie theaters were permitted to reopen earlier this month, along with businesses with recreational activities including darts, racket games and axe throwing.
Comedy clubs, nightclubs and Broadway theaters will open in April, the lawsuit noted.